Updated: Mar 27, 2020
Spectacular rebound... End of the bear market?
In discussing the situation last week, we concluded that depressed stock prices were more of an opportunity than a threat. The reasons ranged from the scale of the decline in risk assets (suggesting that a lot of bad news is expected at these levels) to the imminent deployment of accommodative monetary and fiscal policies (which keep markets functioning and partially offset the halt in economic activity) to the containment measures (which demonstrate that the pandemic can be contained), and the extreme pessimism of investors (which is often a good contrarian signal).
Following a host of negative shocks, it is no surprise that markets reacted swiftly to a ‘better news’ flow. After the Federal Reserve's announcement of infinite quantitative easing, rumours of an agreement on a $2 trillion U.S. fiscal plan have caused the U.S. stock market index to jump more than 10% in the last two days (March 24 and 25). Is this a signal that the bear market is over?
Hold on a second!
Realized market volatility remains extreme. In the face of a multitude of monetary and fiscal measures, drastic containment plans to halt the spread of the coronavirus, and a lack of liquidity in the markets, daily movements have for some time exceeded what is usually recorded in a full year (Chart 1).
However, upswings of this magnitude are more typical of… bear markets (Chart 2)! Is this a signal that the bottom has not yet been reached?
List of key considerations
In order to determine whether the worst is behind us, we are revisiting our list of key elements to observe, as presented on March 18. Specifically:
1. (✔) Concrete fiscal measures to help workers and businesses. The 2 trillion USD budget plan is the most ambitious ever proposed in U.S. history (Chart 3).
2. (X) A slowdown in the growth rate of new cases of COVID-19 worldwide. The situation appears to be stabilizing in Italy with its highest number of new cases on March 20, but it’s markedly deteriorating in the United States, particularly in New York City, where the number of new cases is doubling every three days (Chart 4).
3. (X) Clearer crude oil supply-and-demand fundamentals. World crude oil prices have rebounded from their lows, but the overall trend remains downward (Chart 5) and inventory surpluses offer a poor outlook (more details to come shortly in a Strategic Report).
4. (-) The flow of credit to be restored to households and businesses. The series of extraordinary measures announced earlier this week by the Federal Reserve (purchases of commercial paper, mortgage-backed securities, corporate debt both on the primary and secondary markets, and even direct lending for small businesses) is a major turnaround and should prevent the worst from happening. However, credit risk and liquidity risk gauges remain high (Chart 6).
5. (-) The stock market to consolidate around current levels. Equity prices remain highly volatile, but emerging and European markets have shown signs of stabilization in recent days. U.S. small caps which have been hit harder (-40% from the peak) have also started to recover (Chart 7).
The bottom line
While some factors have improved over the past week, the overall situation remains precarious and still calls for caution. In addition, we should bear in mind that the magnitude of the economic shock remains largely unknown, given the limited post-Coronavirus data available. Granted, stock market valuations have corrected accordingly – the S&P 500's price-to-earnings ratio is near its lowest since 2013 – but it should be noted that the denominator of this popular valuation measure (earnings estimates over the next 12 months as compiled by I/B/E/S) has fallen by only 3% since the start of the crisis. Certainties are rare these days, but 3% is beyond any doubt far too conservative.
The present document was prepared by National Bank Investments Inc. (NBI), a wholly owned subsidiary of National Bank of Canada. National Bank of Canada is a public company listed on the Toronto Stock Exchange (NA: TSX).
The information and the data supplied in the present document, including those supplied by third parties, are considered accurate at the time of their printing and were obtained from sources which we considered reliable. We reserve the right to modify them without advance notice. This information and data are supplied as informative content only. No representation or guarantee, explicit or implicit, is made as for the exactness, the quality and the complete character of this information and these data. The opinions expressed are not to be construed as solicitation or offer to buy or sell shares mentioned herein and should not be considered as recommendations. The opinions are not intended as investment advice nor are they provided to promote any particular investments and should in no way form the basis for your investment decisions. National Bank Investments Inc. has taken the necessary measures to ensure the quality and accuracy of the information contained herein at the time of publication. It does not, however, guarantee that the information is accurate or complete, and this communication creates no legal or contractual obligation on the part of National Bank Investments Inc.
NBI or its affiliates often act as financial advisor, agent or underwriter for certain issuers mentioned herein and may receive remuneration for its services. As well NBI and its affiliates and/or their officers, directors, representatives, associates, may have a position in the securities mentioned herein and may make purchases and/or sales of these securities from time to time in the open market or otherwise.
This document is for distribution only under such circumstances in Canada and to residents of Canada as may be permitted by applicable law. This document is not directed at you if NBI or any affiliate distributing this document is prohibited or restricted by any legislation or regulation in any jurisdiction from making it available to you. You should satisfy yourself before reading it that NBI is permitted to provide this document to you under relevant legislation and regulations.
Commissions, trailing commissions, management fees and expenses all may be associated with mutual fund investments (the “Funds”). Please read the prospectus of the Funds before investing. The Funds’ securities are not insured by the Canada Deposit Insurance Corporation or by any other government deposit insurer. The Funds are not guaranteed, their values change frequently and past performance may not be repeated.
© 2020 National Bank Investments Inc. All rights reserved. Any reproduction, in whole or in part, is strictly prohibited without the prior written consent of National Bank Investments Inc.
® NATIONAL BANK INVESTMENTS is a registered trademark of National Bank of Canada, used under license by National Bank Investments Inc.